Huntington · (631) 240-4390Manhattan · (212) 671-1110
Attorney Advertising
Negligent Security

Parking Lot & Garage Assault Claims in NYC & Long Island

Were you attacked in a NYC parking lot or garage due to poor lighting or security? Leitner Warywoda helps victims file negligent security claims across NYC & Long Island.

The question
Was the crime foreseeable?
Where we practice
NYC · Long Island · Statewide
Fee
No fee unless we recover
Confidential
Case review
Speak directly with our legal staff. No obligation.

Submitting this form does not create an attorney–client relationship. Please do not include confidential or time-sensitive information.

01 · Overview

When Poor Lighting and Security Put You at Risk

Parking lots and garages are among the most common locations for assaults, robberies, and violent encounters—especially in busy cities like New York. When these spaces aren’t properly monitored or maintained, they become targets for crime. If you were injured due to an attack in a parking structure with inadequate lighting, broken gates, or no surveillance, you may be entitled to compensation. Leitner Warywoda helps clients throughout NYC and Long Island hold property owners accountable for negligent security in parking facilities.

02 · Negligent Security

Why Parking Structures Are So Dangerous

Unlike storefronts or lobbies, parking areas are often dim, isolated, and lack constant foot traffic—making them ideal for opportunistic criminals. The most common safety failures we see in these claims include:

  • Burned out or missing lights in stairwells and corners
  • No video surveillance or broken cameras
  • Unattended booths or entry points
  • Non-functioning gates or keycard systems
  • No security patrols despite prior incidents
  • Blind spots where victims can't be seen or heard

Whether you were attacked walking to your car, robbed in an elevator, or injured during a confrontation, the responsibility may rest with the garage operator, building owner, or management company who failed to maintain a secure environment.

03 · Negligent Security

Who Can Be Held Liable for Parking Lot Attacks?

In negligent security cases, the property owner, operator, or manager of the lot or garage may be held responsible. The law looks at whether:

  • The crime was foreseeable, based on location or prior events
  • The security measures in place were reasonable for the area
  • The failure to act directly enabled or worsened the harm

When business owners fail to implement these precautions, they may be liable for injuries that result—even if the crime was committed by a third party. Our job is to prove that better security would have made a difference, and that your suffering could—and should—have been avoided.

04 · Negligent Security

Talk to a NYC Parking Garage Assault Attorney Today

Our legal team is here to support you—not just with the paperwork, but with real investigative power and compassion for what you’ve been through. We’ve handled negligent security claims across Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx, Staten Island, and Nassau & Suffolk Counties, and we don’t stop fighting until our clients get the compensation they deserve.

You shouldn’t have to live in fear because someone failed to protect the space you trusted. Let Leitner Warywoda help you hold them accountable.

How a case proceeds

From the first call to a resolution.

  1. 1

    A real conversation, free

    You tell us what happened. We tell you honestly whether it looks like a case, what the deadlines are, and what we would need to see.

  2. 2

    We investigate before we file

    Records, scene evidence, witnesses, and review by qualified experts. Most of what wins a case is gathered before a complaint is ever served.

  3. 3

    Litigation, built for trial

    Depositions, motions and expert disclosure, prepared as though the case will be tried, because defendants offer their best number to firms that are ready to try it.

  4. 4

    Resolution, your decision

    Settle or try it: that choice is yours, made with a clear picture of the offer, the risk and the timeline.

Results

Recent negligent security recoveries.

All results
$2.65M
Settlement during trial

Slip and fall.

$1.957M
Settlement during trial

Slip and fall.

$600K
Settlement · 2025

Slip and fall on private property.

$400K
Settlement · 2021

Slip and fall on private property.

$375K
Settlement · 2024

Slip and fall involving a municipality.

$362.5K
Settlement · 2022

Premises liability, private property.

Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Questions clients ask

Frequently asked questions.

Who is responsible if I am attacked in a parking garage in New York?

The owner of the garage, the company that operates it, and sometimes a security contractor may be responsible if they failed to take reasonable precautions against a foreseeable crime. Responsibility often depends on who controlled maintenance and security. Common failures include burned-out lights, broken gates or stairwell doors, cameras that are not working, and ignoring prior robberies or assaults at the facility.

Can I sue a parking lot owner for poor lighting after a mugging?

Poor lighting can support a claim if the owner knew or should have known of a risk of crime and the dark conditions helped make the attack possible. You generally must show that the crime was foreseeable, often through prior similar incidents at the lot, and that adequate lighting or other reasonable measures likely would have prevented it. Photographs of the lighting taken soon after the incident can be valuable evidence.

Does it matter whether the parking lot belongs to a store or an apartment complex?

It can. A shopping center, store, or apartment complex that provides parking for customers or tenants generally owes them a duty of reasonable care in that lot, including security that is reasonable for known risks. A municipal lot or a lot at a public facility is a government claim, which usually requires a notice of claim within 90 days. Identifying the true owner and operator early is important, and property records can help.

What should I do after being assaulted in a parking lot or garage?

Get medical attention and report the crime to police so there is an official record. Write down the exact location, such as the level and space number, and photograph lighting, broken gates, or camera locations if you can safely do so. Keep any parking ticket or receipt showing you were there. Ask the operator to preserve surveillance video right away, because many systems overwrite footage within days.

Serious Injury · Wrongful Death

Talk to a trial lawyer today.

Free, confidential review. You pay no fee unless we recover for you.